From the lettuce in your salad, to wheat in your bread, to the grains that feed your chickens — much of the food we eat starts with seed. We rely on seed diversity to sustain and enrich our food systems. Despite this, seed is an often-overlooked aspect of Canadian agriculture.
Since the mid-20th century, public investment in seed development for Canadian agriculture has declined, especially for the organic sector.1 Today, most vegetable seeds used in commercial farming and gardening in Canada are bred internationally and imported.2 This model provides high volumes of quality seed to farmers who need consistency and reliability in their seed supply, but also creates reliance on opaque global supply chains which are vulnerable to interruptions, like the COVID-19 pandemic or international conflicts. Because the majority of seed is bred for non-organic environments, they may require heavier use of nitrogen-based fertilizers and agrochemicals to maintain productivity. These kinds of agricultural practices contribute to 10% of Canada’s greenhouse gas emissions, worsening agriculture’s role in the climate crisis.3 With these mounting challenges, protecting and enhancing Canada’s organic seed diversity has never been more critical.
One solution to these challenges is to advance regionally produced, diverse varieties of organic seed. Regional organic seed strengthens our domestic seed security by supporting regional seed companies and shortening the supply chain, giving organic growers in Canada reliable access to high quality seed. Regional seed companies tend to offer non-proprietary, open-pollinated (“OP”) seeds, which can be reproduced true-to-type and are free of intellectual property restrictions, allowing growers to save and share seed freely. Seeds bred in regional, organic systems produce varieties that are adapted to thrive in dynamic growing conditions, reducing the need for synthetic, fossil-fuel-derived agricultural inputs. They are also bred with regional market preferences in mind, making them especially hardy and delicious.
Collaborative Network
As part of Organic Science Cluster 4, Dr. Loren Rieseberg at the University of British Columbia is leading research on Canadian organic vegetable improvement by integrating genomics, ecophysiology and farmer participation. This work will not only advance regionally adapted vegetable seed in Canada but produce new varieties of salad greens and carrots as well. Dr. Rieseberg has partnered with SeedChange to incorporate this research into the Canadian Organic Vegetable Improvement project (CANOVI).
CANOVI is a collaborative network of farmers and researchers who grow, carefully observe, and evaluate the performance of regional OP vegetable varieties in on-farm conditions.4 This initiative is collaboratively run by The Bauta Family Initiative on Canadian Seed Security (a program of SeedChange) and the University of British Columbia’s Centre for Sustainable Food Systems (CSFS). It focuses on identifying vegetable varieties for their seed production potential, adaptation to organic practices, and agronomic traits of regional interest. Its goal is to strengthen Canada’s organic vegetable seed sector through the trialing and development of varieties that thrive in different regional environments. Since 2018, over 100 farmers have conducted variety trials with over 50 vegetable varieties to evaluate their performance in organic systems. Crops evaluated include peppers, rutabaga, radicchio, and currently, lettuce and carrots.
Leafy Greens
The most recent trialing work has focused on evaluating heat tolerance in leafy greens, an essential market crop for Canadian organic growers. CANOVI participants have noted that head lettuce has become challenging to grow due to the increasingly extreme temperatures brought about by climate change. The CANOVI heat-tolerant lettuce trial, initiated in 2023, evaluates which regionally-produced organic lettuce varieties performed best under summer heat conditions, focusing on their tolerance to bolting (premature flowering), which negatively affects desirable traits in lettuce such as flavour, texture, and colour.
Over two years of trials, the variety Magenta, sourced from Saanich Organics in British Columbia, emerged as the top performer. Growers rated it highly for bolt resistance, uniformity, marketability, flavour, and resistance to diseases and pests. Other standout varieties included Sangria from Salt Spring Seeds in British Columbia and Biscia Rossa from La Société des Plantes in Quebec.
Growers in the trials emphasized that extreme heat is just one of many climate change-related challenges influencing lettuce production. Other issues, such as drought, excess rainfall, and erratic weather patterns are also impacting lettuce production and can lead to stunted growth and bolting. One CANOVI grower highlighted how climate change is also disrupting regional phenology, which is the timing of seasonal cycles and their effects on the natural world. Shifts in phenology make it difficult for growers to time lettuce planting for optimal growth and observation, especially while managing other on-farm priorities. These challenges highlight how trialing lettuce varieties for heat tolerance speaks to climate resilience as well.
Variety trials like these can inform growers about what existing cultivars might best suit their needs; trials can also serve as a precursor to plant breeding projects when growers have a need that cannot be met from the available options. CANOVI is addressing this need through its focus on another essential crop: carrots.
Carrots
Carrots have been a core focus of this work because of their status as a nutritional staple in Canada, their importance as a market crop, and their potential for seed crop production. Despite the crop’s popularity, the majority of carrot seed varieties grown in Canada are hybrids developed in the US and European markets, which may not be well suited to Canadian climates or market preferences, and which cannot be easily saved for seed as OPs can.5
Several years ago, Nelson F1 became suddenly unavailable from seed companies, leaving many growers scrambling to find a replacement. Bolero was identified as ‘next best’ but it is also a hybrid variety offered by just one company in Europe. When growers depend on a variety, it can be devastating to lose access to it and there is no telling when a given company might discontinue a seed offering, or why.
In response to this market change, farmers engaged in the CANOVI project, particularly those in British Columbia, expressed a strong desire to develop their own variety of OP orange storage carrots that performed comparably to the hybrids and could be more easily reproduced and maintained by farmers themselves. The CANOVI network saw an opportunity and began developing the “CANOVI Orange” carrot variety.
CANOVI Orange started in 2019 with crosses between advanced breeding lines from the Carrot Improvement for Organic Agriculture (CIOA) project, a collaboration between Organic Seed Alliance and University of Wisconsin-Madison. Now in 2024, 10 sites across Canada, a mix of ecological farms and universities, took part in a collective selection of carrot roots to include in the CANOVI Orange breeding population. This not only included growing out what roots grew best in the growing conditions but tasting all of the roots too. Together, the best roots will be grown out for seed in 2025 and distributed to participating growers the same year. By decentralizing root selection across diverse sites, the collaboratively-bred CANOVI Orange will incorporate a wide range of genetic diversity, enhancing its resilience to climate change-related challenges faced by growers nationwide. CANOVI hopes to have a delicious and (mostly) stable population that farmers can reliably use by 2028, the end of OSC4.
Carrot varieties take years to develop and there are different agronomic and economic challenges every year but getting to a finished variety is not the only goal. CANOVI is also about the process of building capacity for seed production and plant breeding in Canada; engaging growers in reimagining what public and collaborative plant breeding can look like and keeping seed in the public domain.
Information about The Bauta Family Initiative on Canadian Seed Security can be found at seedsecurity.ca. For more information about the CANOVI project, please visit seedsecurity.ca/canovi.
References
- Kuyek D. 2007. Sowing the seeds of corporate agriculture: The rise of Canada’s third seed regime. Studies in Political Economy, 80(1), 31-54.
- Levert ME. 2014. The market for organic & ecological seed in Canada. Canada Organic Trade Association. https://www.seedsecurity.ca/doc/seedmarketstudy_EN_Dec5.pdf
- Office of the Auditor General of Canada. 2024. Report 5 | Reports of the Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development. Office of the Auditor General of Canada. https://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/att__e_44477.html
- Dang M, Hughes S, Dey A. 2024. Building Climate-Resilient Seed Systems in Canada. SeedChange. https://weseedchange.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Building-Climate-Resilient-Seed-Systems-in-Canada.pdf
- Hart J, Butler M. 2004. Hybrid Carrot Seed. Oregon State University Extension Service. https://extension.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/documents/em8879.pdf; NFU (2024). Fact Sheet: Understanding Seed Import and Export Rules. National Farmers Union. https://www.nfu.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Seed-Import-Fact-Sheet-revised.pdf
Published January 8, 2025
Organic Science Cluster 4 is an industry-led research and development endeavour co-managed by the Organic Federation of Canada and the Organic Agriculture Centre of Canada at Dalhousie University and supported by the AgriScience Program under Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada’s Sustainable Canadian Agricultural Partnership together with over 80 funding partners.